Amy G. Capo - Broker/Owner

Agent Headshot

Phone:(904) 814-6974
Email:amy@amycapo.com

Amy Capo — Trusted REALTOR® in St. Augustine & Northeast Florida Real Estate

Amy Capo is a seasoned and highly recommended REALTOR® specializing in St. Augustine, St. Johns County, and Northeast Florida real estate markets. She expertly serves home buyers and sellers across key zip codes including 32086, 32080, 32084, 32092, and 32095, and neighboring communities. Amy’s strong background in mortgage lending and title services gives her clients a competitive advantage by offering expert guidance on home financing options, real estate contracts, and the closing process for residential properties.

With extensive experience in buyer representation, seller representation, distressed property sales, and senior real estate specialist services, Amy is committed to helping clients navigate the Northeast Florida housing market efficiently and effectively.

Amy holds multiple professional real estate designations including Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR), Seller Representative Specialist (SRS), Seniors Real Estate Specialist (SRES), Certified Distressed Property Expert (CDPE), At Home With Diversity (AHWD), and Transnational Referral Certification (TRC). She is an active member of the National Association of REALTORS®, Florida Association of REALTORS®, Northeast Florida Association of REALTORS®, and the St. Augustine/St. Johns County Board of REALTORS®. In 2026, Amy serves as a member of the Board of Directors for the St. Augustine/St. Johns County MLS, highlighting her leadership role in the local real estate industry.

Recognized for outstanding client service, Amy has earned the Five Star “Best in Client Satisfaction” award from Jacksonville Home Buyer Magazine (2007–2026). She also supports her community through leadership with BNI Old City and mentored with Big Brothers/Big Sisters of St. Johns County.

Outside of real estate, Amy enjoys boating, hiking, college football, and spending quality time with her husband, Byron.

Please, don’t keep me a secret!

Testimonials

Amy is the absolute best in providing market information and helping us to decide to move forward. She is quick to respond and is very capable in her dealings with people. Everything went quickly, smoothly, and efficiently from beginning to end. She was very able in providing support to us and easing our fears. She is our choice and should be for all. We are eager to share our feeling about Amy and her professionalism. Karen & Les S.

Amy did a fantastic job for us. She gave us good advice and was the very epitome of a true professional. She was always Johnny-on-the Spot and responded to our emails and texts within minutes. Her answers were always on target and reflected her deep knowledge and good communication skills. After the closing, there were some items we needed to track down. Since we had already left the area and were not able to address easily, Amy jumped right in and took care of everything for us. We cannot thank her enough. We will wholeheartedly recommend her to our friends and would be willing to provide a testimonial if it would help Amy. Warren & Clare H.

Amy is the most amazing agent! She had our back and made sure everything went smoothly. If you’re buying, selling or thinking about what move to make, Amy is the agent you want in your corner! Rob & Alicia M.

Amy was excellent at taking the house tour for us since we were buying remotely. We talked about what we were looking for and she showed us videos of even nooks and crannies if we asked. She was familiar with the neighborhood so could also provide feedback on living here. She really made this a great process and in a very tight market. Amy was so great to work with! Calmed my anxiety when I fretted, answered every call and every little question, gave great advice and guided us through the whole selling experience. She really knows her stuff, and she really know this area, which is comforting. Thanks, Amy! Signe P.

Amy was so good to us! We have used her for 2 purchases and 1 sale. She was so patient and helpful through the process. Our first purchase was in 2008 and our recent in 2018. Through the ten years Amy was always willing to show us houses even though we knew we weren’t ready to buy. Her genuine kindness and passion for what she does makes her one of a kind. Kristen O.

Amy Capo sold my house in less that 24 hours! She is a rock-star realtor who knows the St. Augustine market inside and out. Lisa W.

Amy is so great! She helped us buy our first house years ago and we were so impressed with her that when we decided to sell that house we knew she was our go to person. Amy is reliable, honest, knowledgeable, and quick to get all of your questions answered. We knew we could trust her and she made selling our house a breeze. We will continue to seek her out if we are ever in that area again! She is the best real estate agent we’ve ever worked with and being in the military we’ve moved all over the country. Definitely recommend to anyone looking to buy or sell in that area. Michelle G.

My husband and I recently had the pleasure of working with Amy to purchase our first home and I really can’t say enough good things about her. She is knowledgeable, approachable, personable, and endlessly patient. She answered every question and explained every form and every part of the process clearly and thoroughly. She is detail orientated and worked to ensure we were prepared for every step of the process. She exceeded all expectation and went above and beyond to make the process as seamless as possible. We highly recommend Amy for all of your real estate needs. Robyn C.

Amy helped us in making our dream come true to live in St. Augustine, in our opinion she deserves more that 5 stars. She looks out for our best interests & communicates well even from another state. Vivian B.

Recently needed to sell my home and was terribly anxious about how to proceed. Amy Capo was great! She handled all the details from beginning to closing. Had my back and led the way. You won’t be disappointed with St. Augustine Key Realty! Karen D.

My agency has closed several transactions with Amy’s company and we have truly enjoyed working with Amy and her customers. Amy is always there to assist when needed and actively follows up with her closings to make sure that no issues come up at the last minute to delay her transactions. Craig H.

We just accidentally found Amy from a website, but we were glad we did. Amy is an excellent realtor who found exactly what we wanted. We were impressed with her ability to follow thru on everything. We would highly recommend Amy. Gerry & Larry R.

Over the years I have sold and purchased over a dozen properties. The most recent one in St. Augustine. While we corresponded over a few months with my list of “requirements”, Amy was diligently searching the availability of those properties that would satisfy. On the very first day of arrival from NH, we found exactly what I was looking for. It was such a pleasure walking into a house/neighborhood that felt exactly like I had come home…. Amy is a realtor at heart. She knows the area, the requirements according to FL law AND, most importantly, she LISTENS!!!! Sheryl H.

Can’t say enough about the excellence in service Amy provided almost 5 years ago when I purchased a foreclosure property in St. Augustine with her. She not only helped to negotiate the best price possible but she also worked with the bank to help our contract stay together when major repair issues showed up at the last minute. Amy’s commitment and dedication to her customers is a quality that is hard to come by. I would recommend Amy to anyone who is looking for a Real Estate Broker who is treat you like family or even better! Laura L.

We just bought our rental house in St. Augustine sight unseen. I never would have considered this if it wasn't for the full trust of Amy. She is so knowledgeable and truly helpful from start to finish. It was such a great experience that we are now working on buying one we can live in :) I HIGHLY recommend her! I have worked with MANY realtors in the past, and Amy runs circles around all of them put together!!! Thank you so much Amy! Alicia B.

Amy was wonderful! She made the whole process of listing and selling my home smooth and effortless. I am so thankful she was my agent. - Cheryl Bacheler

Amy made what I though was going to be a stressful experience as painless as possible. She helped me sell my first home, and only in a few short months. Her communication was incredible! Amy will be assisting with all of my real estate transactions moving forward. 5 stars aren't enough! - Jourdan Spires

Amy Capo is an incredible professional Realtor. Her knowledge of the market and attention to detail is top tier. She always keeps your interest in mind and responds immediately to your phone call or text. She is the best real estate agent I have ever seen. - Tim Cowart